Tag: Aristotle

Freedom Fighters Sent Out To The Sun

A friend and I had a conversation about heavy metal music.  He’s not familiar with metal at all, so I told him a lot of early metal has some blues-scale elements, but the tonality is more aggressive with power chords, overdriven amps, fuzz pedals.  There are themes of dystopian sci-fi, nuclear annihilation and escapism.  The Black Sabbath song Into the Void is about pioneers escaping Earth’s pollution, misery, war, hate, and self-inflicted ruins so they can build another civilization based upon love.  It may not be ideal to escape, because in essence we really can’t escape from our problems by changing locations.  But the song isn’t a self-help guide; rather, it’s just harmless fantasy put to music. It’s exaggerated, cathartic theatre to purge oneself of dark emotions (Aristotle’s Poetics).  I told my friend that it expresses the same archetype as Exodus (Bible), The Aeneid by Virgil, Battlestar Galactica, Wrath of Khan, Blithedale Romance (Nathaniel Hawthorne) and Walden by Thoreau.  They all express the broad sentiment of leaving a corrupt society to live more freely somewhere else.  Their tones are more gentle and philosophical, and they vary in scale (cosmic exile to a cabin in the woods) but they all share the same desire to leave a deeply flawed society to seek out greater freedoms and higher ideals elsewhere.  So that conversation lead to the mention of Interstellar, which I watched a few days ago. 

I’m still trying to wrap Interstellar around my head.  Some of the plot holes distracted me, took me away from the story, and some of it doesn’t make sense.  The parts about truthfulness vs outright lies and deception were great.  The lies lead to Professor Brand (Caine) and Mann (Damon) betraying Coop and Amelia Brand and stranding them in outer space.  The betrayal scenes were great.  It goes back to the skepticism of utopian experiments that Hawthorne expressed.  People can have lofty ideals to build a utopian civilization, but human flaws, ambition, jealously, denial of one’s weakness, deception, and other flaws destroy the experiment.  I loved that part of the film.

I love the theme of the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few, which is echoed in Wrath of Khan.  For the human race to survive, some may need to make great sacrifices.

What confused me was that they lived in dust bowl, but the crops were green.  That confused the heck out of me!  And not to be nitpicky and trivial, but humans can’t live on a diet of just corn.  It seems that the livestock died off.  If they died off from lack of a balanced diet, surely the people would too.  Another of my friends said that it’s the kind of movie where you have to suspend belief in some things in order to make it fun.  I get that.  But why is that the audience’s job?  Overall, it was a decent story though.

Guarding Against Pursuits That Begin and End in Words

I recall being impressed by the the words of Abdu’l-Baha that state “Truthfulness is the foundation of all human virtues” and “Without truthfulness, progress and success, in all the worlds of God, are impossible for any soul.”  These teachings opened my eyes to a profound insight.  No other virtue (honesty, kindness, steadfastness, patience, courage, etc…) can take root if truthfulness is absent.  Truthfulness is the groundwork that we build upon.  

This teaching resonates with, but goes even further, than what I learned from Aristotle’s book Nicomachean Ethics.  Aristotle teaches that moral virtues are best achieved by applying the Golden Mean, which is to find the balanced midpoint between excess and deficiency.  An example would be that when applying the virtue of courage, we need to avoid the excess of courage which would be rashness, and the deficiency of courage which would be cowardice.  While this classical insight shows that all virtues are cultivated by practice, wisdom and balance; the Baha’i Writings elevate the particular virtue of truthfulness as the very foundation of all other virtues, and without it no other virtue can be realized or sustained.  

With this in mind, let us consider two currents in contemporary thought.  Postmodernism and Deconstruction. Postmodernism is an intellectual outlook that arose in the 20th century, and it has roots in 19th century Nihilism.  It casts doubt on the existence of any universal or objective truth, and says that knowledge is shaped by culture, power and individual perspective.  Deconstruction is a method of analyzing everything (writing, institutions, thoughts) to reveal internal contradictions, to show that meanings are never stable, but alway shifting and relative to human perception.  The Baha’i Writings do call upon every person to investigate reality independently, free from imitation or blind following.  However Postmodernism and Deconstruction reject the existence of any stable, universal or objective truth that can be investigated.  They believe that meaning is always constructed by language and power – therefore they undermine the conviction that one can ever arrive at the truth.  This type of search would be a circular, endless spiral that has no possibility of finding a stable moral ground.  This is the antithesis of virtue being built on the stable foundation of truth.  

When exposed to these philosophies we should heed the warnings of Bahá’u’lláh,

“The Great Being saith: The learned of the day must direct the people to acquire those branches of knowledge which are of use, that both the learned themselves and the generality of mankind may derive benefits therefrom. Such academic pursuits as begin and end in words alone have never been and will never be of any worth.”

And also, 

“Knowledge is as wings to man’s life, and a ladder for his ascent. Its acquisition is incumbent upon everyone. The knowledge of such sciences, however, should be acquired as can profit the peoples of the earth, and not those which begin with words and end with words.”

The Kitáb-i-Aqdas further cautions us against sciences that “end in idle disputation.” Shoghi Effendi explained these as “fruitless excursions into metaphysical hair-splittings” and “treatises that encumber the mind rather than help it attain the truth.”

When philosophies systematically undermine the foundation of truthfulness itself, replacing it with a suspicion of all fixed meaning, they risk becoming precisely such pursuits-beginning in sophisticated language and ending only in more sophisticated language, only obfuscating reason, and without uplifting the soul or advancing society.  Let us therefore hold fast to the standard given us: seek knowledge that profits humanity, root every virtue in truthfulness, and turn away from those intellectual trends that, however clever, leave the mind and heart empty. In this way we safeguard the foundation upon which all divine qualities rest and remain true to the purpose of the Baha’u’llah’s Revelation.  

~ Charlie Kirby

In Five Years The Corleone Family Is Going To Be Completely Legitimate

I was asked the question, “Is the purpose of sacrifice, to attain eternal life?”  

My answer is, yes I do think that sacrifice can help one attain eternal life, but I’m not sure I’d say that the purpose of sacrifice is necessarily to attain eternal life.  People can make sacrifices for good, benevolent and magnanimous reasons.  But people can also make sacrifices for selfish, nefarious, harmful or even misguided reasons.  For example a person may sacrifice a regular job and family, to join the mafia, or be a terrorist.  Some cultures have practiced human and animal sacrifice.  Virtues are powerful and we must use discernment when handling them.  Virtues can be a double-edged sword; used widely they build, used without balance they can harm.  Mastering any virtue, including sacrifice, takes practice and skill.    

A literary and film example of sacrifice taken to excess is Michael Corleone in The Godfather trilogy.  Michael chose to sacrifice his post college (Dartmouth) aspirations and personal happiness to do what he framed as necessary service to protect his family.  But even though he ostensibly intended to make the Corleone family business “completely legitimate” he put himself in a position where he got caught in a downward spiral of criminal violence that broke he and his family.  Everything he claimed to serve was progressively destroyed, because he buried the personal and made everything about business.  The line, “It’s not personal Sonny.  It’s strictly business” captures how Michael made great sacrifices to protect his family, but he wound up a slave to power and revenge.  By the end of the trilogy, it is clear that his sacrifice destroyed him, his marriage, and his entire family as he died broken and completely alone. Yes, service to others requires sacrifice, but Corleone’s story shows that one can apply sacrifice in the wrong way, and that without discernment, a well-meaning but misapplied virtue can become utterly destructive and end in tragedy.  This suffering can fester until we cultivate mastery of using the “golden mean” to break the cycle.

One of Aristotle’s ethical principles was the “golden mean” which teaches that when practicing moral virtues, we must find the middle ground between the two extremes of excess and deficiency.  For example with the virtue of truthfulness one would speak honestly when appropriate, and with regard to the hearer’s capacity; however if taken to an excess one’s brutal candor can open needless wounds.  Truthfulness taken to an extreme can also lead to backbiting.  On the other hand, if there is a deficiency in truth, then one can allow falsehood or injustice to stand.  With the virtue of steadfastness one will persevere in the face of difficulties.  Taken to an extreme, steadfastness can lead one to stubbornly “cling to the hem of idle fancies, turning their backs on the hidden Name of the Almighty.”  (Baha’u’llah).  If steadfastness is allowed to go to the state of deficiency, then one quits at the first sign of difficulty.  Can we think of how other virtues would play out if applied with Aristotle’s Golden Mean (the right amount), versus if they are used without discernment and taken to excess or deficiency?  Feel free to share your thoughts.

Baha’u’llah also teaches us to put into practice the principle of “moderation in all things” including virtues such as “Liberty, civilization and the like”  and when they “passeth beyond the limits of moderation” they will “exercise a pernicious influence upon men”.  (quoting from God Passes By)  Just as Aristotle held that virtues become vices through excess or deficiency, Bahá’u’lláh teaches that positive principles and achievements turn harmful when unbalanced. The golden mean is not merely a suggestion, it is essential for human well-being.  In his many treatises on ethics, Aristotle argued that this balance requires skill and practice.

Going back to the virtue of sacrifice, we should also keep in mind that the Universal House of Justice warned Baha’is to not misuse sacrifice.  Sacrifice is a powerful tool.  We must respect it and use it with mindfulness and extreme care so that essential things like the divine institution of family are not destroyed, but strengthened and vitalized.  

“Sacrifice makes possible greater service, but it is not the family itself that is to be sacrificed.”

Universal House of Justice, 2025 letter on Family Life

Shoghi Effendi calls for a practical balance so that one legitimate good does not destroy another.  

“Surely Shoghi Effendi would like to see you and the other friends give their whole time and energy to the Cause, for we are in great need for competent workers, but the home is an institution that Bahá’u’lláh has come to strengthen and not to weaken. Many unfortunate things have happened in Bahá’í homes just for neglecting this point. Serve the Cause but also remember your duties towards your home. It is for you to find the balance and see that neither makes you neglect the other.”

In a letter written on behalf of Shoghi Effendi, 14 May 1929 to an individual believer

https://bahai-library.com/compilation_family_life

Sacrifice for greater ends must never consume the foundation that gives life to those ends, or else the act of service becomes a tragic self-destructive force.  When we stay inside the mean, sacrifice strengthens us as we walk together on a path of service.  

Looking forward to reading your thoughts.  

With Love,

Charlie Kirby